Portable vs. Built-In Ice Makers: Pros and Cons

Posted by Dmitrij Klimchuk on

Ice machines have come a long way since the days of filling up ice trays and waiting patiently for them to freeze. Today, there are two popular types of ice makers: portable and built-in. Each type offers its own set of pros and cons, and the decision between the two may ultimately come down to personal preference and specific needs. In this article, we'll take a closer look at portable vs. built-in ice makers and the benefits and drawbacks of each.

Understanding Portable and Built-In Ice Makers

Ice makers have become an essential appliance in any household or commercial setting. They are a convenient and efficient way to produce ice for drinks, cocktails, and even medical purposes. However, with the different types of ice makers available, it can be challenging to decide which one is best suited for your needs.

Before delving into the specific pros and cons, it's important to first understand what exactly portable and built-in ice makers are.

What is a Portable Ice Maker?

A portable ice maker is a compact, standalone machine that produces ice cubes. These machines do not require any installation and can easily be moved from one location to another. Portable ice makers are perfect for small gatherings or traveling. They are also ideal for outdoor events such as picnics, barbecues, and camping trips. Portable ice makers come in different sizes and can produce varying amounts of ice, so it's essential to choose one that suits your needs.

One of the advantages of a portable ice maker is that it doesn't require any plumbing or installation, making it easy to set up and use.

However, one of the downsides of a portable ice maker is that it has a limited ice production capacity, which may not be sufficient for larger gatherings or events. Portable ice makers also require regular cleaning and maintenance to ensure they function properly.

What is a Built-In Ice Maker?

A built-in ice maker is integrated into the design of a kitchen. These machines are installed under a counter or in a cabinet and are plumbed in by a professional. Built-in ice makers offer a more permanent solution for regular ice usage and are often preferred by large families or businesses.

One of the advantages of a built-in ice maker is that it has a higher ice production capacity than a portable ice maker. This makes it suitable for larger gatherings or events where a lot of ice is required. Additionally, built-in ice makers are more convenient as they automatically refill and produce ice, eliminating the need to refill a water reservoir manually.

However, one of the downsides of a built-in ice maker is that it requires professional installation, which can be costly. It also requires plumbing, which may limit its location options. Built-in ice makers are also more expensive than portable ice makers.

Ultimately, the choice between a portable and built-in ice maker depends on your specific needs and preferences. Portable ice makers are ideal for small gatherings or outdoor events, while built-in ice makers are more suitable for larger gatherings or regular ice usage. Both types of ice makers have their advantages and disadvantages, so it's essential to weigh them carefully before making a decision.

Pros of Portable Ice Makers

Easy Installation and Mobility

One of the biggest advantages of a portable ice maker is that it requires no installation. Unlike built-in models, which need to be plumbed into your home's water supply, portable ice makers can be set up and ready to use in just a few minutes. This makes them an excellent choice for those who want to enjoy the convenience of having ice at home without the hassle of a complicated installation process.

Another great thing about portable ice makers is that they're, well, portable. Whether you're hosting a party in your backyard or camping in the great outdoors, a portable ice maker can keep you supplied with ice no matter where you are.

Lower Initial Cost

Another advantage of portable ice makers is that they're generally less expensive than built-in models. This makes them a great option for those who want to enjoy the convenience of having ice at home without breaking the bank. In fact, you can find high-quality portable ice makers for as little as $60, making them an affordable choice for just about anyone.

Of course, the lower cost of portable ice makers doesn't mean you have to sacrifice quality. Many portable ice makers are made from durable materials and are designed to last for years with proper care and maintenance.

Variety of Sizes and Styles

One of the best things about portable ice makers is that they come in a wide variety of sizes and styles. Whether you're looking for a compact and sleek model that can fit on your countertop, or a larger and more rugged model that can handle heavy use, there's a portable ice maker out there that's perfect for your needs.

Some portable ice makers even come in fun and funky colors, making them a great way to add a pop of personality to your kitchen or home bar.

No Drain Required

Finally, one of the biggest advantages of portable ice makers is that they don't require any plumbing or a drain source. This means you can use them practically anywhere, whether you're in your kitchen, or even on a boat or RV.

Overall, there are many great reasons to choose a portable ice maker over a built-in model. From their easy installation and mobility to their lower cost and variety of sizes and styles, portable ice makers are a convenient and affordable way to enjoy ice at home or on the go.

Cons of Portable Ice Makers

Limited Ice Production

Portable ice makers are a great option for those who need small amounts of ice. However, if you're looking to produce large amounts of ice, a portable ice maker may not be the best option. Built-in ice makers can produce a larger quantity of ice in a shorter amount of time, making them a better choice for those who need a lot of ice on hand.

Manual Water Refilling

Portable ice makers require manual water filling, which can be inconvenient for those who need a consistent supply of ice. However, this can also be seen as an advantage as it allows for more control over the quality of the water used to make the ice.

Shorter Lifespan

Because of their compact design and lower price point, portable ice makers typically have a shorter lifespan than built-in models. However, with proper maintenance and care, a portable ice maker can last for several years. It's important to regularly clean the ice maker and follow the manufacturer's instructions for use to ensure that it lasts as long as possible.

Overall, while portable ice makers may have some limitations, they can be a great option for those who need small amounts of ice or who need a portable ice maker for different locations. With proper care and maintenance, a portable ice maker can be a reliable source of ice for years to come.

Pros of Built-In Ice Makers

Higher Ice Production Capacity

Built-in ice makers are designed to produce a larger amount of ice on a regular basis. This is great for large families or businesses who require a continuous supply of ice. With the ability to produce up to 50 pounds of ice per day, built-in ice makers can keep up with even the most demanding ice needs.

Continuous Ice Supply

With a built-in ice maker, you never have to worry about running out of ice. The machine continuously produces ice, ensuring a constant supply. This is especially useful for events or parties where a large amount of ice is needed at once. You can rest assured that your guests will always have access to ice-cold drinks.

Customizable Integration with Kitchen Design

Because built-in ice makers are designed to be integrated into a kitchen's design, they can be customized to match the style and decor of the room. This can add to the overall aesthetic appeal of the kitchen. With a variety of finishes, colors, and styles available, you can choose an ice maker that complements your kitchen's existing design.

Additionally, some built-in ice makers come with a panel-ready design, which allows you to install a custom panel that matches your cabinetry. This creates a seamless look that blends in with the rest of your kitchen.

Longer Lifespan

Due to their more durable and permanent design, built-in ice makers typically have a longer lifespan than portable models. This means that they may need to be replaced less frequently, saving you money in the long run.

Furthermore, built-in ice makers are often equipped with high-quality components that are designed to withstand the wear and tear of daily use. This ensures that your ice maker will continue to function at optimal levels for years to come.

Increased Home Value

Installing a built-in ice maker can increase the value of your home. This is because many homebuyers are looking for modern and convenient features, such as a built-in ice maker, when shopping for a new home. By adding this feature to your kitchen, you may be able to attract more potential buyers and increase the overall value of your home.

Cons of Built-In Ice Makers

The main drawback of built-in ice makers is that they require professional installation and plumbing. This can be costly and time-consuming, and may not be feasible for those who live in rental properties or plan to relocate in the near future. Additionally, built-in ice makers are often more expensive than portable models, which may not be realistic for some budgets.


When it comes down to it, the decision between portable and built-in ice makers depends on individual needs and preferences. For those who require a consistent and larger supply of ice, a built-in ice maker may be the better option. For those who want the convenience of having ice wherever they go, a portable ice maker does the job just as well. Ultimately, it's important to weigh the pros and cons of each type and decide which one fits best with your lifestyle and budget.

← Older Post Newer Post →



Ice Makers: The Perfect Gift for a Chilling Halloween

By Dmitrij Klimchuk

Halloween is a holiday filled with thrills, chills, and plenty of opportunities for spooky surprises. While costumes, decorations, and candy play a significant role in...

Read more

How to Clean and Maintain Your Ice Maker and Ice Molds for Longevity

By Dmitrij Klimchuk

Ice makers are a convenient appliance to have in your home or office. They provide a steady supply of ice whenever you need it. However,...

Read more